Overhaul of Pumps No. 1 & No. 5, Fox Point Hurricane Barrier, Providence, RI
How Chas G. Allen, Inc. rebuilt two of the 650,000 GPM pumps that protect the City of Providence from coastal flooding, delivered on time and rated “Outstanding” by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.
Overview
Built in the 1960s after the devastating 1938 New England Hurricane, the Fox Point Hurricane Barrier protects the City of Providence from coastal flooding. Its five Worthington Hi-Flo pumps, each moving 650,000 GPM and driven by a 4,500 HP motor, are the core of the city’s storm defense.
In 2010, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) found fractured propeller vanes in Pumps No. 1 and No. 5. Chas G. Allen, Inc. won the fixed-price contract to disassemble, inspect, overhaul and recommission both units.
Project Challenges
- Fractured propellers. Vanes weighing more than 600 lb each had cracked on the 119-inch impellers, and Pump No. 1 had lost an entire vane. The cause traced back to latent defects in the original 1960s Ni-Resist castings: brittle material and a poorly designed vane hub root thickness.
- Decades of wear. After decades in brackish water, the shafts, bearings, columns and diffusers showed erosion, cracking, pitting and signs of inadequate lubrication.
- Hand-drawn originals. The only schematics were hand-drawn, so parts had to be reverse-engineered and digitized before they could be fabricated or upgraded.
- Lead-containing materials. Paint and component materials contained lead, so all cleaning and coating had to meet strict USACE and EPA environmental standards.
Our Approach
- Engineering analysis and redesign. Digital modeling pinpointed the structural weaknesses, and we improved the impeller design to distribute stress better and last longer.
- Precision repair and fabrication. We fabricated a new propeller and keys for each unit, replaced the lower bearing brackets with upgraded ductile Ni-Resist castings, and rebuilt and upgraded the upper and lower bearings in Monel 400 and 420 stainless steel.
- Testing and alignment. Ultrasonic testing and precision alignment verification held tolerances under 0.002 in.
- Protective coatings. Carboline and Belzona coating systems restored and protected surfaces exposed to brackish water and heavy tidal activity.
- Mechanical systems overhaul. We disassembled, cleaned and rebuilt the gearheads, sluice gate operators, anti-rotation brakes, lubrication systems and electrical temperature monitoring.
Results
November 2011
Pump No. 5 back in service
June 2012
Pump No. 1 fully recommissioned
On time
Delivered despite 20 change orders and outside utility delays
“Outstanding”
USACE final evaluation, with praise for quality, responsiveness, documentation and safety
Zero
Reported safety incidents or compliance violations
“The Contractor worked diligently to quickly finish any and all punch list items and any warranty items that have come to light. They responded with corrective action within 48 hours to any required warranty item.”
Services Provided
- Full disassembly and inspection
- Reverse engineering and failure analysis
- Custom fabrication of propellers, shafts and bearing components
- NDT, mechanical alignment and precision assembly
- Environmental coatings and metal restoration
- Testing, documentation and recommissioning
Need a Quote?
Have a critical pump that needs the same level of care? Tell us about your project.